Was the Dublin Murder TV show different from Tana’s French books?


Dublin Murders came to a mind-boggling conclusion and some of our burning questions have finally been answered.

We found out Rosalind was behind Katie’s death and the twisted reason she orchestrated the murder of her own sister.

However, some viewers were frustrated with the lack of responses to the 1985 affair which saw Adam / Rob’s best friends Jamie and Peter disappear.

The Dublin murders finally came to an end last night. Photo: BBC Murders / RTE / Dublin

The eight-part series of the Dublin Murders is based on two books by author Tana French; In the woods and the resemblance.

However, readers were shocked at the direction the show took with some elements of the TV show that were very different from the books.

Killian Scott and Sarah Green as Rob Rilley and Cassie Maddox in Dublin Murders. Photo: BBC

Extra.ie noticed some huge differences after the first two episodes, but, now that the series is over, it’s safe to say that the TV series was loosely based on the books.

Here are the main differences that we spotted.

Magic woods

The last episode of Dublin Murders showed Rob (Killian Scott) meeting Frank (Tom Vaughan-Lawlor) outside of the woods in Knocknaree.

Frank handed Rob a piece of wood and said there was a picture of the “Child Snatcher” on it.

As Rob walked away, there was a wolf watching Frank.

There was no magic in the woods in the books like there was in Dublin Murders. Photo: Steffan Hill / BBC

It just didn’t happen in the books.

There were so many wolves, no magic, and no child thieves.

There was also no one who wrote ‘he rises’ and said that a dark force lived in the mysterious woods.

We never found what happened to Jamie and Peter in the Dublin Murders or in the books. Photo: Steffan Hill / BBC

We never found out what happened to Jamie and Peter and the book ended there. He didn’t try to conclude anything and it was extremely frustrating.

Dublin Murders dove deep into the idea of ​​satanic rituals and dark forces as the book dismissed them pretty bluntly.

That being said, I think it was a good addition to the TV show and it meant viewers got a tiny bit of closure, even though they weren’t happy with the outcome.


Rob was a completely different character in Dublin Murders than in the book In The Woods.

Although he had a breakdown in the books, it was nothing like the downward spiral he pursued on the show.

Rob has become destructive in his quest to find out who killed Katie in the hopes of finding out what happened in the woods of Knocknaree in 1985.

Rob was a completely different character in Dublin Murders than in the books. Photo: Jonathan Hession / BBC

He fought with Sam, yelled at his poor mom and assaulted suspects.

One of the biggest differences with Rob, however, was the way he treated Cassie (Sarah Greene).

While Rob and Cassie’s relationship changed after having sex in the books, Rob treated her much better.

The Dublin Murders have ruined the character of Rob for readers of the books. Photo: Steffan Hill / BBC

Viewers were rocked by the way Rob treated Cassie after their scorching night and it really changed the way many of us looked at the character of Killian Scott.

It’s safe to say that Rob only treated Cassie like that because he denied being in love with her, but it still tainted a lot of people’s perception of him.

For me, I like Rob much better in the books than in the series and I feel really touched by the way his character turned out.

Cassie’s Time Undercover as Lexie

The whole second book was based on Cassie’s time undercover as Lexie.

This means that Tana French was able to give much more detail about Cassie’s time with the weird students.

In parts of the second book, Cassie developed Stockholm Syndrome and spent a lot more time in the house than the Dublin Murders left.

Cassie has spent a lot more time undercover as Lexie in the books than in the series. Photo: BBC Murders / RTE / Dublin

The whole Lexie Mangan story was a lot more in-depth and complicated in the books than it was in Dublin Murders, and to be honest I feel like the series didn’t do the book justice.

We also got some sort of closure in the books on Lexie and her true identity in the books. We saw Cassie spreading her ashes in the last episode and she had been classified as Jane Doe and we never got to find out who she really was.

Rosalinde’s confession

Viewers’ jaws were on the ground when Rosalind admitted to planning the murder of her sister.

In Dublin Murders, she was arrested at her home, brought to the police station and asked to be interviewed by Cassie.

The case was then put in jeopardy and Rosalind’s future was on the line as she denounced Rob as Adam.

Rosalind’s case was put at risk over the Dublin murders when she revealed that Rob was in fact Adam. Photo: Bernard Walsh / BBC

In the book, Rosalind’s confession was much more suspenseful and Cassie had to cheat on her into confessing.

Cassie knocked on the Devlin’s door and told him she wanted to go for a walk and talk about her affair with Rob.

Carrying a hidden mic, Cassie finally made it clear to Rosalind that she had murdered Katie.

The murder squad must have gotten Rosalind out of a confession from the books, but she confessed freely in the Dublin Murders. Photo: Steffan Hill / BBC

There was a constant ‘won’t she won’t’ feeling in the books and you just weren’t sure if she would confess.

As with the Dublin Murders, Rosalind’s case was tossed in the books, but that was in part because the Murder Squad interviewed her without a parent or guardian knowing. ‘she was a minor.

While Rosalind has revealed that Rob is Adam in the books, he wasn’t put in the spotlight like he was in Dublin Murders. This fact has been kept a secret so that it does not affect the matter.

Love / Hate’s Killian Scott and Rosie Sarah Greene star in Dublin Murders. Photo: BBC

Due to the huge differences between Dublin Murders and In The Woods and The Likeness, you can go back and read the novels even if you’ve seen the TV show.

But be warned; if you are hoping for answers you won’t find what you are looking for.

Source link


About Author

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply